Merit planning, built into your annual review

Scholarly connects faculty performance ratings to salary increases in a single workflow. Set guidance once, see every department’s merit budget as decisions are made, and keep a record of who changed what, without passing spreadsheets between offices.

2027 Annual ReviewMerit planningDepartment of Chemistry
In progress
Merit pool · 3% of eligible pay
$44,910of $48,372 allocated
14 eligible faculty$3,462 remaining
Rating distribution36% rated Exceeds, above your 20% guidance
Substantially exceeds · 2 (14%)Exceeds · 5 (36%)Meets · 6 (43%)Needs improvement · 1 (7%)
Faculty memberFinal ratingFinal meritCurrent payMerit amountFinal compensation
Dana WhitfieldExceeds expectations4.5%$142,000+$6,390$148,390
Priya RamanSubstantially exceeds5.5%$131,200+$7,216$138,416
Marcus OyelaranMeets expectations3.0%$118,500+$3,555$122,055
Hannah LindqvistExceeds expectations4.0%$109,750+$4,390$114,140
Tomás ReyesMeets expectations3.0%$96,800+$2,904$99,704
Owen AchebeNeeds improvement1.0%$101,300+$1,013$102,313

The Old Way

Merit decided outside the review

Two processes for one decision. The annual review runs in one place and merit runs in another, so ratings get retyped into a salary file.

A spreadsheet for every chair. Each department gets a file of salaries, fills it in and emails it back. The version history is someone’s inbox.

Budget goes unchecked until the end. No one knows a department is over its merit budget until someone adds up every row.

Guidance in a memo. The rating-to-raise guidelines live in a PDF, and applying them consistently is up to each reviewer.

No record of how a number changed. When a faculty member asks why their increase moved between the chair and the dean, the answer is in old email.

With Scholarly

Ratings and raises in one process

Merit Planning runs on Scholarly workflows. Add it to the annual review you already run in Scholarly, and the steps that collect faculty input and chair and dean reviews also produce a final rating, a merit increase and a new salary. Or run merit as its own workflow, separate from the review. Either way, everyone works from the same live numbers, and the decision history stays with each case.

01

Set the rules

Choose who is eligible, size the merit pool, the money set aside for raises, as a percentage of pay or a fixed amount, and set the increase you expect for each rating.

02

Rate and recommend

Chairs and deans rate faculty in the review steps they already use. Scholarly fills in the recommended increase from your guidance, and reviewers adjust where they need to.

03

Balance and finalize

Administrators see every group’s budget and rating mix as decisions come in, adjust increases right in the table, then generate letters and export the results.

Features

Everything you need to run your merit cycle, from setting guidance to sending the final letters.

Every raise starts from your policy

Tell Scholarly what each rating should earn, for example, a 4–5% merit raise for receiving the rating “Exceeds Expectations”. When a chair or dean picks a rating, the recommended increase fills in on its own, with your guidance right beside it. Those reviewing salary changes start from policy instead of a blank box, and can still adjust when a case calls for it.

Final rating
Exceeds expectations
Final merit
Merit guidance for Exceeds Expectations: 4.0–5.0%Recommended merit: 4.5%
4.5%
Filled from guidance
Studio Arts Needs attention
$52,180 allocated of $47,600 pool$4,580 over
Chemistry In progress
$44,910 allocated of $48,372 pool$3,462 left
History Done
$31,725 allocated of $31,980 pool$255 left

See each department’s pool, in real time

Set the pool as a percentage of eligible faculty pay or as a fixed dollar amount. As increases are entered, Scholarly totals what each group has allocated against its pool and flags any group that goes over budget. Salaries are locked in when planning begins, so a raise that takes effect mid-cycle doesn’t move the budget.

The whole cycle on one screen

A cycle-wide view lists every department with its plan status, eligible faculty and ratings ready. The provost’s office can see which groups are finished, in progress or need attention, without asking each department for an update. Groups with decisions ready for review are flagged so nothing goes unnoticed.

GroupStatusEligibleRatings ready
Studio ArtsNeeds attention1212 / 12
Chemistry 2 ready for reviewIn progress149 / 14
BiologyIn progress216 / 21
MathematicsNot started170 / 17
HistoryDone1111 / 11
EconomicsDone1515 / 15
Merit guidance · Chemistry
RatingMerit guidanceDistribution guidanceFacultyAvg. increase
Substantially exceeds5.0–6.0%Up to 15%2 (14%)5.5%
Exceeds expectations4.0–5.0%Up to 20%5 (36%)4.4%
Meets expectations2.5–3.5%—6 (43%)3.0%
Needs improvementUp to 1.0%—1 (7%)1.0%

Ratings that match expectations

Set distribution guidance for each rating, such as “no more than 20% of faculty can receive Exceeds Expectations.” Each group shows its actual rating mix, with the number of faculty and the average increase at each rating, so outliers are visible before decisions are final.

One annual review for everyone, salary adjustments for those who qualify

Everyone completes the same annual review. Eligibility rules decide who is in the merit pool, using rank, department, tenure status, appointment details, custom fields or answers from earlier in the workflow. Faculty who aren’t eligible, or a whole department that isn’t, go through their annual review without seeing any merit steps.

Merit eligibility
Faculty are eligible when all of these are true
Appointment FTEis at least0.5
Rankis notEmeritus
Compensation changenone betweenJan 1 – May 31
Add condition
412 of 486 faculty in this workflow are eligible
Final ratingExceeds expectations
Final merit4.0%
New salary$114,140
  1. Final Merit changed from 3.5% to 4.0%Dean, College of Arts & Sciences · Mar 11, 3:42 PM
  2. Final Merit changed from 4.5% to 3.5%Chair, Department of Chemistry · Mar 4, 2:20 PMJustification: Lower increase reflects missed grant and teaching goals.
  3. Final Merit set to 4.5% from guidanceScholarly · Mar 4, 2:14 PM

A record of every decision

Each change to a rating or merit increase is logged on the case with who made it and when, and whether it came from guidance or from a reviewer. When an increase falls outside guidance, the reviewer adds a justification that stays with the record. Each faculty member’s merit tab shows their performance result, merit decision and salary together.

More in Merit Planning

Configurable merit table

Add any workflow question as a column, such as a chair’s comments, and order the columns the way reviewers read them.

Edit in place

Make a change directly in the merit table and every total will update.

Letters on your letterhead

Generate a letter for each faculty member with their final rating, merit increase, and new salary when a step completes.

Payroll-ready export

Export final salaries, increases and effective dates to Excel in one click for your HR or payroll system.

Compensation API

Read and write compensation records through the Scholarly API to keep Scholarly and your HR system in sync.

Compensation permissions

Decide which roles can see or edit salary information, so reviewers see only what they’re allowed to.

Any pay period

Record pay as annual, monthly, weekly, daily or hourly, and Scholarly converts it to annual pay for the pool.

Faculty and staff

Merit Planning isn’t limited to faculty. Staff can go through the same merit process, with their salaries tracked the same way.

Designed for everyone in the merit cycle

Provost offices and faculty affairs.

See every department’s status, budget and rating mix in one view, and spot the groups that need a conversation before the deadline does.

Compensation and HR teams.

Lock the salary base when planning starts, apply eligibility rules consistently, and get a payroll-ready export with a log of every change behind it.

Deans and chairs.

Rate and recommend in the review steps you already use, with guidance beside each decision and your pool in view. No workbook to download and send back.

Faculty members.

Complete one annual review, not two. When the cycle closes, your letter shows your rating, and when eligible your increase and your new salary.

Built for a decision that is part judgment, part budget

Merit is a conversation between chairs, deans and the people who hold the budget. Scholarly gives everyone the same numbers and guidelines to work from.

Guidance, not a formula.

Recommended increases are a starting point. Reviewers can change any of them, and updates outside guidance are flagged for review, not blocked.

Ratings when you use them.

Schools that tie raises to a rating scale and schools that recommend increases without one can each run their own workflow.

A budget that holds still.

Pay is locked in when planning begins, so the pool doesn’t shift as new salary records arrive mid-cycle.

Private by default.

Salary data is visible only to the roles you choose at each step.

Room for exceptions.

Rules handle the common cases. A custom field can add or exclude someone with a contractual exception, and the record shows why.

A paper trail you can stand behind.

Every change to a rating or increase is logged with who made it and when, so the answer to “why did this move?” is on the case.

How Merit Planning works

01

Bring in compensation

Load effective-dated salary records from your HR system through an integration, file import or the API, or administrators can enter them manually.

02

Set the rules

Add Merit Planning to your annual review or set it up as its own workflow, then set eligibility, the pool, and merit and distribution guidance for each rating.

03

Rate & recommend

Faculty submit their self-review. Chairs and deans set ratings, and Scholarly fills in the recommended increase for them to confirm or adjust.

04

Balance the pools

Track every group’s budget and rating mix as decisions come in, and adjust increases in the merit table until each pool balances.

05

Finalize and export

Generate letters on your letterhead and export final salaries, increases and effective dates for HR or payroll.

Designed for the workflows you already run

If your annual review already runs on Scholarly, Merit Planning can add to that workflow instead of starting a new one. If it doesn’t, Merit Planning can run on its own as a standalone merit cycle.

Learn more about workflows

Faculty self-evaluation

Faculty self-evaluation

Chair review and rating

Chair review and rating

Dean review and merit planning

Dean review & merit planning

Letters and faculty acknowledgment

Letters & faculty acknowledgment

Frequently Asked Questions

What is merit planning?

Do we need to run our annual review in Scholarly to use Merit Planning?

Where does salary data come from?

How is the merit pool calculated?

Who can see compensation information?

Can some faculty complete the annual review without being eligible for a raise?

Can different schools run merit differently?

What happens when the plan is final?

How is this different from the merit tools in our HR system?

See your merit process in Scholarly

See your merit process in Scholarly

See your merit process in Scholarly

We’ll walk through how your institution runs merit today and show it working in Scholarly.

© 2026 Scholarly Software, Inc. All rights reserved.

Colorado Office

2150 W. 29th Avenue

Suite 520

Denver, CO 80211

Washington Office

506 2nd Ave

Suite 920

Seattle, WA 98104

© 2026 Scholarly Software, Inc. All rights reserved.

Colorado Office

2150 W. 29th Avenue

Suite 520

Denver, CO 80211

Washington Office

506 2nd Ave

Suite 920

Seattle, WA 98104

© 2026 Scholarly Software, Inc. All rights reserved.

Colorado Office

2150 W. 29th Avenue

Suite 520

Denver, CO 80211

Washington Office

506 2nd Ave

Suite 920

Seattle, WA 98104

© 2026 Scholarly Software, Inc. All rights reserved.

Colorado Office

2150 W. 29th Avenue

Suite 520

Denver, CO 80211

Washington Office

506 2nd Ave

Suite 920

Seattle, WA 98104